I have yet to understand what's so good and cool in "cap, cap, cap" strategy which most ABers seem to love.
I will first define two strategies:
Capping: Focus on capping, avoid battles
Killing: Focus on smart killing, cap when killing isn't possible
Luxon squad captures a shrine. Kurzick squad captures a shrine.
Cap strategy: Both run past each other and go cap. Result: Equal shrines
Kill strategy: One squad kills the other one. Result: Equal shrines, points from killing and enemy squad disabled for a while.
According to this, cap strategy is low risk, low reward. And killing strategy is high risk (low if you are good), high reward.
And second thing which I can't understand. Once our side is losing, people start screaming "cap more!!!". If we focus on capturing, we can only win if they fail with killing strategy. And as we are already losing, I doubt they use bad strategies.
PC Gaming News
Results 1 to 10 of 114
Thread: Capping, just don't get it
28-11-2008, 13:16 #1
Capping, just don't get it
Last edited by Wethospu; 28-11-2008 at 19:46.
28-11-2008, 16:04 #2
Having capped flags gets you points faster than killing.
Originally Posted by http://guildwars.wikia.com/wiki/Alliance_Battle#Battle_Objectives
28-11-2008, 16:18 #3
Just killing is bad strategy because you do not gain points fast enough to win. That said, the trick is not only to cap, but to defend or offend shrines when required as well; especially strategically points like the res shrines. Also, avoid fighting the mob, because that's a pointless fight.
28-11-2008, 17:29 #4
And what if you have 8 vs 4 and you could easily kill them fast? Split and go cap shrines?
And what about my example situation?
28-11-2008, 18:47 #5
28-11-2008, 18:56 #6
I don't think you guys are quite getting what he means.
A luxon team and a kurzick team both cap a shrine. They run circles around each other, and just keep capping over each other. There's no gain.
In the second scenario, both teams cap the shrines like before, but then I get our team to charge the luxons, utterly destroy their faces, cap over their shrine, and then move over to cap the next one. We're up two shrines compared to the previous example.
28-11-2008, 19:44 #7
28-11-2008, 19:57 #8
28-11-2008, 20:09 #9
GWOnline Site Pal Achievements:
- The Order of Dii [Dii]
It's a good question, but I think you don't have the right tradeoff.
Either strategy will give a tie if both teams are matched in strength. The point here is that you're comparing the rewards for capping vs killing.
Pro's for capping:
1) By avoiding fights, you can run faster to the other shrines and cap them faster.
2) You also can bring specialized builds to that effect.
3) You can also split more.
Pro's for killing:
1) You get points for killing enemies.
2) You can still cap, but at a slower rate.
So in the example, when the capping team meets the killing team in the middle, the killing team will start casting offensive spells. They might kill 1 or 2 opposite team members. But they will have to stop running in order to do so, or even run back towards the shrine they already capped in order to get the kill.
Meanwhile, the capping team keeps the original shrine, and might even have enough time to at least disable the other shrine. Thus they gain a shrine advantage.
So basically, it's not true that you can cap & kill without trade-off.
28-11-2008, 20:39 #10
I have no idea how you figure that you can run faster and split more if you're capping, nor how a "specialized build" for capping is any different from a normal one. Why the hell would you ever not bring a speed boost in AB? By killing people capping certain shrines, you get the Battle Cry bonus which increases your run speed to +25%. That plus the run boosts everyone should have anyway, means there's hardly any time lost killing people and capping their shrines.
And you can "split more?" What? Again I don't see how choosing to kill teams or avoid them has any bearing on this. I don't need a specific 'capping build' to go split off and solo a ranger shrine on my warrior, for god sakes. Hell, you don't even need a self heal for that, just dodge their attacks while going in and/or position a post between them and you.
And I don't care what kind of build you have, you won't get more accomplished by being able to 'split more,' because you'll be taking so many skills to increase your survivability or mobility you won't be able to kill a damn thing. Eg: Know who wins between a tank w/mo and a smart warrior with a good build and no self heal? The latter.
Just.. seriously. What.
"Ok, got that shrine, let's move onto the next one! Oh wait, there's a team that's moving in to cap it! Let's just completely ignore them, let them finish capping it, and move onto the next one!"
Seriously. You have got to be joking me.